COMPARE PRODUCTS

The Butternut Co. vsThe Whole Truth - Compare Ratings & Lab-test Results

The Butternut Co. Peanut Butter Crunchy | Unbox Health Lab Ratings, Reviews
cross icon
The Whole Truth Peanut Butter Crunchy - Dark Chocolate | Unbox Health Lab Ratings, Reviews
cross icon
VS
Unbox Health Ratings heart icon
Rating:
C
Previously Rated:
A
Ratings Details
Label Accuracy Score
7
Non-Toxicity Score
5.61
Nutritional Profile Score
8.45
Label Accuracy Score
8.97
Non-Toxicity Score
10
Nutritional Profile Score
8.79
Summary
Whole Truth Peanut Butter received a higher rating (A) vs Butternut Co Peanut Butter (C) in Unbox Health's independent lab tests, based on higher Non-Toxicity Score, Label Accuracy Score, Nutritional Profile Score.
Label Accuracy: Whole Truth Peanut Butter (8.97 out of 10) received a higher score than Butternut Co Peanut Butter (7 out of 10).
Non-Toxicity: Whole Truth Peanut Butter (10 out of 10) received a higher score than Butternut Co Peanut Butter (5.61 out of 10).
Nutritional Profile: Butternut Co Peanut Butter (8.45 out of 10) and Whole Truth Peanut Butter (8.79 out of 10) received similar scores.
Lab Test Results
32.05
g
Total Protein
26.52
g
14.6
g
Total Carbs
35.21
g
52.65
g
Total Fat
33.28
g
6.12
g
Dietary Fibre
9.77
g
3.81
g
Total Sugar
15.44
g
43.41
g
MUFA+PUFA
25.23
g
9.24
g
Saturated Fat
8.05
g
0
g
Trans Fat
0
g
26.46
mg
Sodium
128.6
mg
8.68
ppb
Total Aflatoxins
3.58
ppb
7.2
ppb
Aflatoxin B1
3.32
ppb
0
ppm
Lead
0.11
ppm
0
ppm
Arsenic
0
ppm
0.02
ppm
Cadmium
0.04
ppm
0
ppm
Mercury
0
ppm
Product Details
Crunchy | Claims per 100g: 32g Protein, 15g Carbs, 50g Fat, 3g Sugar, --g Fibre, --g Saturated Fat, --g PUFA+MUFA, --g Trans Fat, --mg Sodium.
Crunchy | Claims per 100g: 25.7g Protein, 40.2g Carbs, 32.1g Fat, 13.6g Sugar, 8.8g Fibre, 4.4g Saturated Fat, 27.7g PUFA+MUFA, 0g Trans Fat, 78.8mg Sodium.
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS

The Butternut Co. vs The Whole Truth: Which product is better?

Unbox Health FAQ Icon

Butternut Co Peanut Butter received a rating of (C) and Whole Truth Peanut Butter received a rating of (A). Unbox Health rates products from D to A+ after testing every product at multiple accredited labs for their label accuracy, toxicity and nutritional profiles. Unbox Health is an unbiased third-party - we do not recommend or endorse any products. Please refer to the comparison table above to make an informed decision.

What is the difference between Butternut Co Peanut Butter and Whole Truth Peanut Butter?

Unbox Health FAQ Icon

Butternut Co Peanut Butter received a rating of (C) and Whole Truth Peanut Butter received a rating of (A) in Unbox Health's independent lab tests.

  • Label Accuracy: Whole Truth Peanut Butter (8.97 out of 10) received a higher score than Butternut Co Peanut Butter (7 out of 10).
  • Non-Toxicity: Whole Truth Peanut Butter (10 out of 10) received a higher score than Butternut Co Peanut Butter (5.61 out of 10).
  • Nutritional Profile: Butternut Co Peanut Butter (8.45 out of 10) and Whole Truth Peanut Butter (8.79 out of 10) received similar scores.

See the comparison table above for the exact tested values.

Is Butternut Co Peanut Butter good for health?

Unbox Health FAQ Icon

Whether Butternut Co Peanut Butter is good for your health depends on individual dietary needs. Unbox Health does not label products as healthy or unhealthy, it tests them independently and lets the data decide. Butternut Co Peanut Butter scored (C) overall, with Label Accuracy 7/10, Non-Toxicity 5.61/10 and Nutritional Profile 8.45/10. Check Unbox Health's lab data for Butternut Co Peanut Butter before deciding.

Is Whole Truth Peanut Butter good for health?

Unbox Health FAQ Icon

Whether Whole Truth Peanut Butter is good for your health depends on individual dietary needs. Unbox Health does not label products as healthy or unhealthy, it tests them independently and lets the data decide. Whole Truth Peanut Butter scored (A) overall, with Label Accuracy 8.97/10, Non-Toxicity 10/10 and Nutritional Profile 8.79/10. Check Unbox Health's lab data for Whole Truth Peanut Butter before deciding.

Where can I see the lab test results for Butternut Co Peanut Butter and Whole Truth Peanut Butter?

Unbox Health FAQ Icon

The full lab test results for Butternut Co Peanut Butter and Whole Truth Peanut Butter, including tested nutrient and safety parameter values, are shown in the comparison table above. You can also view each product's complete lab report on their individual product pages.

Which is safer — Butternut Co Peanut Butter or Whole Truth Peanut Butter?

Unbox Health FAQ Icon

Whole Truth Peanut Butter (10 out of 10) received a higher Non-Toxicity score than Butternut Co Peanut Butter (5.61 out of 10) in Unbox Health's independent lab tests. Non-Toxicity scores measure unsafe contaminant levels (heavy metals, aflatoxins and others) against FSSAI safety limits. See the comparison table above for the exact contaminant values.

Which has better Label Accuracy — Butternut Co Peanut Butter or Whole Truth Peanut Butter?

Unbox Health FAQ Icon

Whole Truth Peanut Butter (8.97 out of 10) received a higher Label Accuracy score than Butternut Co Peanut Butter (7 out of 10) in Unbox Health's independent lab tests. Label Accuracy measures how closely tested nutrient content matches the brand's declared label claim. See the comparison table above for the exact tested versus claimed values.

What are the units used for the values listed in the comparison table above?

Unbox Health FAQ Icon

For Food Products: All nutritional values are listed on a per 100g basis.

For Supplements & Nutraceuticals: All ingredient values are listed on a per capsule/tablet basis.

How many labs were used to test these products?

Unbox Health FAQ Icon

Every product gets tested at multiple accredited international labs, which gives us multiple data points per parameter per product. We use these data points to arrive at a single consensus value for each parameter based on our robust consensus rules.

If a product contains Heavy Metals or Aflatoxins at levels > 0, does that mean it is unsafe?

Unbox Health FAQ Icon

No, many products may contain Aflatoxins or Heavy Metals (like lead, arsenic, cadmium, mercury) at levels > 0. This does not mean they are above legal safety limits. Please refer to the Non-Toxicity Score of the product to determine if they were found to be unsafe for consumption.

  • Values of 0ppm for lead, arsenic, cadmium, mercury should be interpreted as approximately zero. Trace amounts (at levels below the detectable limit) may still be present.
  • Values of 0ppb for aflatoxins should be interpreted as approximately zero. Trace amounts (at levels below the detectable limit) may still be present.

Share icon
The Butternut Co. vs The Whole Truth Peanut Butters | Which is better?